The new TITO board arrived and it didn't work either. Looking closer at it the instructions all say to set it up for host comm 1. I looked inside the cabinet and something else is plugged into host comm 1 so I configured the settings to host comm 2, which is what the TITO devices have been plugged into this whole time. After doing that I got the original TITO to work with free play. Thank you for the support here, I will mark this thread as solved.