If you are open to suggestion (and don't mind a little extra work) you would probably make more money putting them on eBay in batches of 100, 200 or 300.
A couple years ago I had a boatload of Fannini $1 tokens I needed to unload. I listed them on eBay and if memory serves me correctly, they wound up selling for around $0.55 each with the buyer paying shipping. To keep buyer shipping costs low, I packed them in USPS Priority Mail flat rate boxes that were heavily wrapped in packing tape and they shipped for around $15.00.